Selected Reviews

The Reviews

A curated selection from hundreds of reviews across more than fifty countries. The complete texts live on the Full Reviews page. For the new novel, From Before Memory, see the home page.

Legend of a Suicide

From 80 selected reviews · winner of 10 prizes · published in 22 languages

“One of the best writers of his generation.”

— Le Figaro

“The great American novel we’ve awaited.”

— Le Point

“A masterpiece.”

— France Inter

“One of McCarthy’s true heirs. A writer is born.”

— Sud Ouest

“A powerful new voice has emerged in fiction.”

— The Sunday Times

“Quite possibly the finest American debut of the year.”

— The Independent

“Unputdownable.”

— The London Evening Standard

“Vengeful yet sorrowing, plausible yet dreamlike, and completely absorbing.”

— The Guardian

“Hands down the best fictional debut we have read this year.”

— Dazed and Confused

“Exactly what fiction should do.”

— BBC Radio 4, Saturday Review

“A seriously impressive work of literature.”

— BBC World Service

“This book — merciless and loving — is a modern American masterpiece.”

— Het Parool

“Magnificent.”

— Télérama

“A pure diamond.”

— Femme Actuelle

All reviews · 77 indexed

  • Tom Bissell, New York Times Book Review
  • The Times Literary Supplement, Books of the Year 2009
  • The Irish Sunday Independent
  • The Weekend Australian
  • The London Observer
  • Lorrie Moore, The New Yorker Book Club
  • The Times
  • Le Figaro
  • Le Point
  • France Inter (Radio)
  • France Info (Radio)
  • Telerama
  • Femme Actuelle
  • Le Canard Enchaine
  • Sud Ouest
  • Livres Hebdo (France)
  • BBC World Service
  • The San Francisco Chronicle
  • National Geographic Adventure
  • The Guardian
  • The Financial Times
  • The Sunday Times Culture Profile
  • The Sunday Times review
  • The Independent on Sunday
  • The Sunday Telegraph
  • The Independent
  • The London Evening Standard
  • The Courier Mail (Australia)
  • The Sydney Morning Herald
  • The Sunday Canberra Times
  • The Daily Mail
  • Julie Myerson, Prospect Magazine
  • David Mills, Esquire UK
  • Florence Welch, lead singer of Florence and the Machine
  • MarieClaire UK
  • Grazia
  • Harper’s Bazaar
  • Sarah Broadhurst, The Bookseller
  • Lionel Shriver
  • Ross Raisin
  • Philip Hoare
  • Nadeem Aslam
  • Alex Clark, Waterstone’s Books Quarterly magazine
  • Robert Olen Butler
  • Publishers Weekly
  • Stewart O'Nan
  • Men's Journal
  • Noy Holland, Gracy Paley Prize Judge
  • Times Literary Supplement
  • The Australian Best Books of the Year
  • Tom Sutcliffe, BBC Radio 4 Saturday Review
  • David Aaronovitch, BBC Radio 4 Saturday Review
  • John Carey, BBC Radio 4 Saturday Review
  • Guardian Christmas Books
  • The Literateur Magazine
  • Dazed and Confused
  • RTL (French Radio)
  • Le Figaro Magazine
  • Le Matricule des Anges
  • NRC Handelsblad (Dutch daily newspaper)
  • Nu.nl (5-star review)
  • De Standaard (5-star review)
  • Wim Brands on VPRO Boeken Television
  • Financieele Dagblad
  • CJP Magazine
  • Trouw
  • Het Parool (*****)
  • De Pers (free daily newspaper)
  • HUMO
  • Suddeutsche Zeitung
  • Die Welt
  • Frankfurter Rundschau
  • Luxemburger Wort
  • Markische Allgemeine Zeitung
  • Landeszeitung fur die Luneburger Heide
  • Deutschlandradio Kultur
  • Zeit-online

Caribou Island

From more than 100 reviews in English and French

“My favorite novel of the past few years.”

— The Paris Review

“Literary masterpiece.”

— Anchorage Daily News

“A work of art.”

— El País

“Compared to Caribou Island, The Road is grim-lit lite.”

— London Review of Books

“The harsh beauty of Alaska is the star turn in Vann’s disturbing novel.”

— The New Yorker

“Vann is a forceful, potent writer.”

— The Guardian

“Writing born of tremendous passion.”

— The Sunday Telegraph

“Vann keeps the pages turning with the skill of the best mystery novelists.”

— Associated Press

“An existential page-turner and literary breakthrough.”

— Kirkus

“A taut and riveting study of isolation, insanity, and violence.”

— Men’s Journal

All reviews · 50 indexed

Dirt

Winner of the $50,000 St. Francis College Literary Prize

“Words and ideas seem almost dangerous in his hands.”

— New Statesman, Best Books of the Year

“Brave and brilliant.”

— The Washington Post

“Extraordinary. It is sword-literature.”

— France Inter, Le Masque et la Plume

“Very effective, this novel is toxic and intense.”

— L’Express

All reviews · 35 indexed

  • San Francisco Chronicle
  • The Economist
  • The Observer
  • The Washington Post
  • TROUW (2-page spread) (Dutch language edition of Dirt)
  • Éric Neuhoff, LE FIGARO LITTÉRAIRE
  • André Clavel, LIRE
  • Laurant Fialaix, QUESTIONS DE FEMMES
  • François Perrin, TGV Magazine
  • Le Masque et la plume, France Inter
  • LIVRE HEBDO
  • MARIANNE PAYOT, L'EXPRESS
  • GILLES HEURÉ, FRANCE INTER
  • Bernard Quiriny, LE MAGAZINE LITTÉRAIRE
  • Denver Post
  • The New Yorker
  • London Evening Standard
  • The Paris Review
  • The Wall Street Journal
  • BookPage
  • Kirkus
  • Booklist
  • The Daily Beast
  • San Jose Mercury News
  • The California Report
  • Canberra Times
  • Slate.com
  • Metro (London)
  • TheBookbag.co.uk
  • Publisher's Weekly
  • Sunday Star Times (New Zealand)
  • New Zealand Listener
  • The Australian
  • Boston Globe
  • Shelf Awareness

Goat Mountain

Now being filmed by Nar Films

“He’s doing something fearless with allegory and character.”

— San Francisco Chronicle

“Structurally, the novel is as reliable as liturgy.”

— The Washington Post

All reviews · 36 indexed

  • San Francisco Chronicle Recommended Books
  • Toby Lichtig, Wall Street Journal and Times Literary Supplement
  • The Times (London)
  • New Statesman
  • Starred Library Journal review
  • Publishers Weekly
  • Booklist
  • Sunday Telegraph
  • The Weekend Australian
  • San Jose Mercury News
  • Brisbane Courier Mail (Australia)
  • (5 stars) Jennifer Somerville, Good Reading (Australia)
  • The Melbourne Review and The Adelaide Review
  • Sunday Star Times (Australia)
  • Launceston Examiner (Australia)
  • The Bookworm (Terri Schlichenmeyer)
  • de Volkskrant (****) (Netherlands)
  • De Standaard (****) (Netherlands)
  • Het Parool (****) (Netherlands)
  • Nu.nl (****½) (Netherlands)
  • Boek Magazine (Netherlands)
  • The Thousands (Australia)
  • Bookbag.co.uk
  • Goat Mountain
  • Robert Morgan, Author of GAP CREEK
  • Robert Olen Butler, author of the Pulitzer Prize-winning
  • A Good Scent from a Strange Mountain
  • Kirkus
  • Metro (New Zealand)
  • The National (United Arab Emirates)
  • The Burr
  • Sydney Morning Herald
  • Thom Conroy, The Listener (New Zealand)
  • WeLoveThisBook.com
  • Longmire
  • Ismet Prcic

Aquarium

A New York Times Book Review Editors’ Choice · starred reviews in Kirkus, Booklist & Library Journal

“As rich as good poetry and as addictive as a first-class detective novel.”

— The Spectator

“A triumph.”

— Daily Mail

“A stirring tale that isn’t as simple as it first appears.”

— Esquire UK

All reviews · 14 indexed

  • Sheryl Cotleur, Copperfield’s Books, Sebastopol, CA
  • The Spectator (UK)
  • Lydia Millet, The New York Times Book Review
  • Donna Chavez
  • Daily Mail (UK)
  • Esquire UK
  • Weekend Australian
  • A New York Times Book Review Editors' Choice
  • A March 2015 Indie Next Great Read
  • Al Woodworth
  • Library Journal starred review
  • Kirkus starred review
  • Booklist Starred Review
  • Publishers Weekly

Last Day On Earth

Winner of the AWP Nonfiction Award

“A carefully crafted account of a descent into fatal madness.”

— Kirkus Reviews

All reviews · 4 indexed

  • Lee Gutkind, founding editor, Creative Nonfiction
  • Max Winter, Boston Globe
  • Kirkus Reviews
  • Criminal Law and Criminal Justice Books

A Mile Down

Bestseller · Washington Post #4 · Los Angeles Times #7

“Damn exciting.”

— Stewart O’Nan

“As if a hero of The Perfect Storm had lived to write his memoirs.”

— Julie Hilden

“Mandatory reading for anyone who’s flirted with a life at sea.”

— A. Manette Ansay

All reviews · 6 indexed

  • Stewart O’Nan
  • Robert Morgan, author of Gap Creek and Brave Enemies
  • Julie Hilden, author of 3 and The Bad Daughter
  • Lalita Tademy, author of Cane River
  • Keith Scribner, author of The Goodlife and Miracle Girl
  • Stan Honey, Navigator for Pyewacket, Cheyenne, ABNAmro